Efficacy of δ18O data from Pliocene planktonic foraminifer calcite for spatial sea-surface temperature reconstruction; comparison with a fully coupled ocean-atmosphere GCM and fossil assemblage data for the mid-Pliocene

Online Access: Get full text
doi: 10.1017/S0016756805000828
Author(s): Williams, Mark; Haywood, Alan M.; Hillenbrand, Claus-Dieter; Wilkinson, Ian P.
Author Affiliation(s): Primary:
British Antarctic Survey, Geological Sciences Division, Cambridge, United Kingdom
British Geological Survey, United Kingdom
Volume Title: Geological Magazine
Source: Geological Magazine, 142(4), p.399-417. Publisher: Cambridge University Press, London, United Kingdom. ISSN: 0016-7568 CODEN: GEMGA4
Note: In English. 101 refs.; illus., incl. 4 tables
Summary: Sea surface temperature (SST) estimates using the δ18O composition of fossil planktonic foraminifer calcite, within the time slice 3.12 to 3.05 Ma (Pliocene, Kaena Subchron-C2An1r) are assessed for nine Atlantic Ocean sites. These are compared with SST estimates from fossil assemblages for the "Time Slab" 3.29-2.97 Ma and with estimates from a fully coupled ocean-atmosphere General Circulation Model (GCM) for the same time interval. Most SST estimates derived from the δ18O data indicate a cooler ocean surface than at present, through the latitudinal range 69.25° N to 46.88° S. At some sites the temperature difference is greater than 5 °C (cooler than at present). This contrasts with SST estimates from fossil assemblages that give warmer than present temperatures at mid- to high latitudes, and similar temperatures in the tropics, and with the GCM, which predicts SSTs warmer than at present across all latitudes for this time interval. Difficulties interpreting the ecology of fossil foraminifer assemblages and inaccurate estimates of mid-Pliocene seawater δ18O composition (δ18Osw) at some sites may partly produce the temperature discrepancy between isotope-based and fossil-based SST estimates, but do not adequately explain the cool signal of the former. We interpret the cool SST estimates from the δ18O data to be the product of: (a) calcite formed at a level deep within or below the ocean mixed-layer during the life-cycle of the foraminifera; (b) secondary calcite with higher δ18O formed in the planktonic foraminifer tests in sea bottom pore waters. Although these effects differ between sites, secular and temporal oceanographic trends are preserved in the primary calcite formed in the mixed-layer near the ocean surface, witnessed by the latitudinal variation in estimated SSTs. Reconstructing accurate mid-Pliocene SSTs with much of the existing published oxygen isotope data probably requires a detailed re-assessment of taphonomy, particularly at tropical sites. This study also indicates that methods for estimating Atlantic Pliocene δ18Osw need to be refined.
Year of Publication: 2005
Research Program: DSDP Deep Sea Drilling Project
ODP Ocean Drilling Program
Key Words: 02 Geochemistry; 12 Stratigraphy, Historical Geology and Paleoecology; Algae; Assemblages; Atlantic Ocean; Calcite; Carbonates; Cenozoic; Chronostratigraphy; Deep Sea Drilling Project; Dentoglobigerina; Dentoglobigerina altispira; Diatoms; Foraminifera; General circulation models; Geochemistry; Geologic thermometry; Globigerinacea; Globigerinidae; Globigerinoides; Invertebrata; Isotope ratios; Isotopes; Kaena Subchron; Leg 108; Microfossils; Middle Pliocene; Neogene; North Atlantic; O-18/O-16; ODP Site 659; ODP Site 907; Ocean Drilling Program; Oxygen; Paleoclimatology; Paleoecology; Paleoenvironment; Planktonic taxa; Plantae; Pliocene; Protista; Reconstruction; Rotaliina; Sea-surface temperature; Sphaeroidinellopsis; Sphaeroidinellopsis seminulina; Stable isotopes; Tertiary
Coordinates: N691459 N691459 W0124154 W0124154
N180437 N183438 W0210134 W0210135
Record ID: 2005072344
Copyright Information: GeoRef, Copyright 2019 American Geosciences Institute. Abstract, Copyright, Cambridge University Press, Reference includes data from GeoScienceWorld, Alexandria, VA, United States